Crystal Shop UK · Rooted in intention, curated with care

Book of Shadows: What It Is and How to Start One

A Mystic Grove guide cover in sage and cream on white, with a crescent moon between botanical sprigs above a line drawing of an open book, titled Book of Shadows.

What the phrase actually means, who coined it, and a way to begin that does not need a plan

Almost everyone who keeps a book of shadows starts the same way: they buy a beautiful blank book, open it, and freeze. The first page feels like it ought to be perfect, which is exactly the thing that stops it being written. It helps to know that the whole idea is younger than most people assume, that the first famous one was rewritten by somebody who thought it needed improving, and that there has never been a correct version to live up to.

What a book of shadows actually is

A working notebook for a practice. That is the whole of it.

What goes inside varies completely from one person to the next, because the point is usefulness rather than completeness. Someone who works with herbs fills one with growing notes and infusion timings. Someone who reads cards fills one with spreads and what came of them. Someone who follows the turning year fills one with dates, weather and what they did. None of these is wrong, and none of them is the official version, because the official version does not exist.

The misunderstanding worth clearing first is that a book of shadows is a book you receive. In the tradition that coined the phrase it was, once, copied by hand from a teacher. For almost everyone using the words now it is a book you write.

Where the name came from

The phrase is twentieth century, and the trail runs through one man and one magazine.

Gerald Gardner, the retired civil servant whose writing did more than anything else to shape modern witchcraft in Britain, is where it enters general use. The account of how he picked it up comes from Doreen Valiente, who was there and who knew him well.

Her version is this. In 1949, The Occult Observer carried an article called The Book of Shadows, written by a palmist named Mir Bashir, about what he described as an ancient Sanskrit manual for foretelling events by measuring the length of a person’s shadow. In the same issue, on the facing page, ran an advertisement for Gardner’s novel High Magic’s Aid. Valiente believed he took the phrase from that article and applied it to the witches’ book.

Worth being careful here: this is Valiente’s account rather than a documented admission, and it has not been independently confirmed. It is the best explanation anyone has, which is a different thing from a proven one.

What is firmer is that the name does not describe the contents. A manual for divining by shadow lengths has nothing in common with a book of rituals and recipes. The phrase was borrowed for its sound, which is usually how good names happen.

The part that usually gets left out

Gardner’s own draft survives. A manuscript in his handwriting, titled Ye Bok of Ye Art Magical, was found among his papers after his death and reads as an early version of what became the Book of Shadows. It carries a good deal of material drawn from Aleister Crowley’s ritual work, which Gardner had access to from 1946.

Then Doreen Valiente joined his coven in 1953 and in time became its High Priestess. Reading the book properly, she recognised where the parts had come from: Crowley, Aradia, the old grimoire literature and Freemasonry, rather than the unbroken ancient line Gardner had described.

She said so. Gardner conceded that what he had been given was fragmentary and that he had filled the gaps himself, and told her that if she thought she could do better she should go ahead.

She did. Valiente rewrote a great deal of it, cut most of the Crowley material, kept what she thought was worth keeping, and wrote new text of her own, including the version of the Charge of the Goddess that is still the one most people know.

This is the useful part. The most influential book of shadows there has ever been was not received intact from anywhere. It was assembled, questioned by someone who knew her sources, and then substantially rewritten by her because the first draft was not good enough. If that is how the famous one came about, the pressure to get yours right first time is pressure you have invented.

Book of shadows or grimoire?

These two words get used as though they are interchangeable, and there is a real distinction underneath, though nobody polices it.

Grimoire Book of shadows
Roughly A manual of technique A record of a practice
Written for Anyone who can follow it The person keeping it
Tone Instructional, impersonal Personal, often dated
Age of the word Old, from the French for grammar Twentieth century
Typically holds Correspondences, procedures, seals All of that, plus what happened
A rough division rather than a rule. Plenty of people keep one book and call it either name depending on the day.

In practice most people keep something closer to a book of shadows and borrow the grimoire habit of writing procedures down clearly enough that they can be repeated.

How to start one

The freeze at the first page is a planning problem, so the cure is to stop planning.

Bound or loose leaf

A bound book is a pleasure to hold and punishes mistakes. A ring binder is less lovely and lets you reorder everything once you discover how you actually use it. A reasonable compromise is a binder for the first year and a bound book afterwards, once you know what the sections want to be.

Do not start at the beginning

Leave the first eight or ten pages blank and start writing a third of the way in. Those front pages become the contents and the reference tables later, once you know what they need to hold. Starting in the middle also removes the ceremony of the first page, which is the thing that was stopping you.

Date everything

Every entry, every time. This is the single habit that turns a notebook into a record you can actually learn from, because it lets you look back and see what you were doing in a particular season or under a particular moon, and whether it went anywhere.

Write what happened, not only what you intended

The entry that earns its place six months later is the one with the outcome on it. What you did, what you used, and then, in a different colour or a week later, what came of it. Most books are full of plans and empty of results, which makes them lovely and useless.

ONE WAY TO DIVIDE IT Front pages, left blank contents and tables, filled in last The turning year dates, weather, what you did Correspondences stones, herbs, colours, hours Workings and what came of them Readings the spread, then the outcome Anything else quotes, dreams, half ideas Start a third of the way in and work outwards

ONE WAY TO DIVIDE IT Front pages, left blankcontents and tables, filled in last The turning yeardates, weather, what you did Correspondencesstones, herbs, colours, hours Workingsand what came of them Readingsthe spread, then the outcome Anything elsequotes, dreams, half ideas Start a third of the way in and work outwards

Six divisions that tend to earn their keep. Treat it as a starting shape to argue with rather than a template to fill.

Questions people ask

Does a book of shadows have to be handwritten?

No, though handwriting is the common preference and there is a practical reason beyond the romance of it. Writing by hand is slow, and the slowness makes you choose your words, which tends to produce a more useful record than typing does. A file you actually keep beats a beautiful book you avoid.

Can anyone keep one, or is it only for initiates?

Anyone. The copied, teacher to student version belongs to specific initiatory traditions. The general use of the phrase, which is how nearly everyone means it, carries no such requirement.

What should go on the first page?

Nothing, for now. Leave the front blank, start further in, and let the opening pages be written once you know what the book turned out to be about.

Should I keep it private?

That is a preference rather than a rule, and it usually settles itself. A book with real outcomes in it, including the disappointing ones, is more honest when nobody else is going to read it. Some people keep a second, tidier book for anything they want to share.

What if I write something and later decide it was nonsense?

Leave it and date your change of mind underneath. A book that records how your thinking shifted is worth considerably more than one that has been quietly tidied into always having been right.

Shop the books in this guide

A book you like the feel of, something to write with, and nothing else. The binder and the bound book both work, so pick by how you like to make a mess.

Books of shadows and grimoires · Journals and notebooks

If you are filling in the sections: the Agrippa guide explains where correspondence tables came from in the first place, the sigil guide gives you something to put under workings, and the cleansing notes cover the practical end.

Keep reading

More from Ritual and Altar

See everything in Ritual and Altar

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *